You’re posting consistently. You’re using hashtags. You even bought a ring light. But your engagement is still flatlining – and you can’t figure out why.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: most brands are making the same social media marketing mistakes over and over again, and the algorithms are punishing them for it. The average engagement rate on Instagram sits at just 0.48% in 2025 (per Social Insider). On Facebook and X, it’s even worse – around 0.15%. TikTok leads the pack at 2.50-3.70%, but even there, bad habits will tank your numbers fast.
Let’s break down the 12 social media marketing mistakes to avoid if you actually want people to see, like, and share your content. Results-driven, no vague advice – just real fixes you can use this week.
1. Posting Without a Strategy (aka “Winging It”)
This is the single most common mistake, and it’s the one that makes every other mistake worse. You sit down, think “I should post something today,” throw up a random quote graphic, and call it marketing.
That’s not marketing. That’s noise.
What goes wrong: Your content has no cohesion. Your audience doesn’t know what to expect from you. The algorithm can’t categorize your account, so it doesn’t know who to show your posts to. You end up reaching nobody.
The fix: Build a simple content calendar with 3-5 content pillars. For example, a fitness brand might rotate between workout tips, client transformations, nutrition advice, behind-the-scenes, and Q&A posts. Plan at least two weeks ahead. You don’t need fancy software – a Google Sheet works fine. The point is intentionality, not perfection.
2. Ignoring Your Analytics Completely
If you’re not checking your analytics at least weekly, you’re flying blind. I’ve seen businesses post at 9 AM every day for months when their audience is most active at 7 PM. They had no idea because they never looked.
What goes wrong: You keep repeating what doesn’t work. You miss patterns – like the fact that your carousel posts get 3x more saves than your single images, or that your audience drops off every Sunday. Without data, you’re just guessing.
The fix: Set a weekly 15-minute analytics check. Look at three things: (1) which posts got the most engagement, (2) when your audience is online, and (3) what format performed best. Every platform gives you this data for free. Use it. Adjust your strategy monthly based on what the numbers actually say.
3. Buying Followers (Yes, People Still Do This)
It’s 2026 and brands are still buying followers. Here’s what happens: you pay $50 for 10,000 followers. Your follower count looks impressive for about a week. Then your engagement rate craters because those fake accounts never like, comment, or share anything.
What goes wrong: Instagram, TikTok, and every other platform can detect fake followers. Their algorithms measure engagement rate – not follower count – to decide whether to push your content. A 50,000-follower account with 12 likes per post is a red flag. The algorithm buries you. Real potential followers see the mismatch and don’t trust you. Brands checking your account for partnerships notice immediately.
The fix: There’s no shortcut here. Delete fake followers if you’ve bought them (yes, you can remove followers on Instagram). Focus on growing 100 real, engaged followers instead of 10,000 ghosts. One engaged follower who shares your post with their network is worth more than 50,000 bots.
4. Inconsistent Posting (The Feast-or-Famine Cycle)
You post five times in one week because you’re feeling inspired. Then nothing for three weeks. Then a burst of seven posts in two days. Sound familiar?
What goes wrong: Every platform’s algorithm rewards consistency. When you disappear for weeks, the algorithm stops showing your content to your existing followers – you have to essentially re-earn your reach. Studies from Later and Hootsuite consistently show that accounts posting 3-5 times per week outperform accounts that post the same total number of times but in irregular bursts.
The fix: Pick a realistic schedule you can maintain for 6 months. Three posts a week is better than seven posts followed by silence. Use scheduling tools like Buffer, Later, or the native scheduling features built into Meta Business Suite and TikTok. Batch-create content on one day so you’re not scrambling daily.
5. Not Engaging With Comments and DMs
Need help with your social media strategy?
We help businesses and individuals build engaged audiences and drive real results through social media.
This one drives me crazy. You spend an hour creating a post, someone takes the time to leave a thoughtful comment, and you just… ignore it. That’s like inviting someone to a party and then not talking to them when they show up.
What goes wrong: The algorithm tracks whether you respond to comments – especially in the first 30-60 minutes after posting. Engagement breeds more engagement. When you don’t reply, the conversation dies, the algorithm notices the post isn’t generating back-and-forth interaction, and it stops pushing it out. Your followers also learn that commenting on your posts is a waste of their time, so they stop.
The fix: Block off 15 minutes after every post goes live to respond to every comment. Ask follow-up questions in your replies to keep the thread going. Respond to DMs within 24 hours. This single habit can double your engagement rate because the algorithm sees active conversation and pushes your content further.
6. Using the Wrong Hashtags (or Way Too Many)
Stuffing 30 hashtags on every Instagram post with things like #love #inspo #photooftheday isn’t a strategy. Those mega-hashtags have billions of posts – yours gets buried in seconds. And on LinkedIn, more than 3-5 hashtags looks spammy and actually hurts reach.
What goes wrong: Generic hashtags attract bots and random accounts, not your target audience. Your post competes against millions of others. Worse, Instagram’s algorithm has moved toward topic-based distribution – it reads your caption and image to understand your content. Irrelevant hashtags confuse the system and hurt your reach.
The fix: Use 5-15 hashtags on Instagram (the sweet spot based on recent data). Mix three categories: niche-specific (under 100K posts), mid-range (100K-1M posts), and a couple of broader ones. On TikTok, 3-5 targeted hashtags work best. On LinkedIn, stick to 3. The goal is relevance, not volume. Search each hashtag before using it – if the content there doesn’t match yours, skip it.
7. Making Every Post a Sales Pitch
“Buy now! Link in bio! 50% off! Limited time!” – if this is every other post on your feed, you’ve already lost. People don’t follow brands on social media to get sold to. They follow for entertainment, education, or inspiration.
What goes wrong: Your followers tune out. Promotional posts consistently get the lowest engagement rates across every platform. The algorithm sees low engagement, shows your posts to fewer people, and suddenly even your non-promotional content gets buried because your account’s overall engagement score has dropped.
The fix: Follow the 80/20 rule – 80% value content (tips, entertainment, stories, education) and 20% promotional. Some marketers prefer 90/10. The point is: earn the right to sell by giving value first. When you do promote, make it feel natural – show the product in use, share a customer story, or frame it as solving a problem rather than just pushing a discount code.
8. Ignoring Short-Form Video
If you’re still only posting static images in 2026, you’re leaving massive reach on the table. TikTok’s average engagement rate is 5-7x higher than Instagram’s static post engagement. Instagram Reels get roughly 2x more reach than photo posts for most accounts. YouTube Shorts are growing fast.
What goes wrong: Every major platform is prioritizing video content in their algorithms. Not because they hate photos – but because users spend more time watching videos, and platforms want to maximize time-on-app. If you refuse to adapt, your content gets less distribution over time as video-first accounts take your audience’s attention.
The fix: You don’t need a production studio. Start with simple talking-head videos, behind-the-scenes clips, or quick tips filmed on your phone. Aim for 30-90 seconds. Add captions (85% of social video is watched without sound). Post at least 2-3 short-form videos per week alongside your other content. The barrier to entry is much lower than you think.
9. Copying What Competitors Do Instead of Testing
“Well, our competitor posts motivational quotes every Monday, so we should too.” Stop. You have no idea if their motivational quotes actually perform well. Maybe those posts get 10 likes while their behind-the-scenes content gets 500. You’re copying their worst strategy and calling it research.
What goes wrong: You end up with a generic account that looks like everyone else in your industry. Your audience has no reason to choose you over the competition because your content is interchangeable. You also miss opportunities that are unique to your brand’s voice and strengths.
The fix: Run your own experiments. Test different formats, topics, and posting times for 4-6 weeks. Track what works for YOUR audience – not someone else’s. By all means, look at competitors for inspiration, but filter everything through your own data. What works for a 500K-follower account won’t necessarily work for a 5K-follower account.
10. Neglecting Your Bio and Profile
Your bio is your storefront. When someone discovers one of your posts and clicks through to your profile, they make a decision in about 3 seconds: follow or leave. If your bio is vague, your profile picture is blurry, and there’s no clear indication of what you do or why they should care – they leave.
What goes wrong: You get profile visits but almost no new followers. Your follow-back rate (the percentage of profile visitors who actually follow) tanks. This is a huge leak in your funnel that most brands never even measure.
The fix: Your bio should answer three questions in under 150 characters: (1) What do you do? (2) Who is it for? (3) What’s in it for them? Add a clear call-to-action and a link. Use a high-quality, recognizable profile picture – your logo for brands, your face for personal brands. Pin your 3 best posts to the top of your grid so new visitors see your strongest content first.
11. Posting the Same Content Across Every Platform
Taking your Instagram caption, pasting it on LinkedIn, tweeting the first sentence, and uploading the same image to Facebook is not a multi-platform strategy. Each platform has different audiences, different norms, and different algorithms.
What goes wrong: A vertical Reel that kills it on Instagram looks terrible as a LinkedIn post. A long-form LinkedIn thought piece gets zero traction on TikTok. Your audience on each platform expects content tailored to that platform’s format and culture. Cross-posting without adapting signals laziness, and the algorithms can tell when content wasn’t optimized for their platform.
The fix: Repurpose, don’t copy-paste. Take one core idea and adapt it for each platform. A blog post becomes a carousel on Instagram, a thread on X, a short video on TikTok, and a discussion post on LinkedIn. Same message, different packaging. If you don’t have time to adapt for every platform, pick 2-3 and do them well rather than doing 5 platforms poorly.
12. Giving Up Too Soon
Here’s the mistake nobody talks about. You implement a new strategy, post consistently for three weeks, don’t see explosive growth, and conclude that “social media doesn’t work for our industry.” Three weeks is nothing.
What goes wrong: Social media growth is compounding, not linear. Most accounts don’t see significant traction until months 3-6 of consistent effort. The algorithm needs time to understand your content and find your audience. Every time you quit and restart, you reset that learning process. You’re essentially starting from zero again.
The fix: Commit to a minimum of 90 days before evaluating whether your strategy is working. Set realistic benchmarks – not “go viral” but measurable goals like “increase engagement rate from 0.5% to 1.5%” or “grow followers by 20% in 90 days.” Track progress monthly. Adjust tactics along the way, but don’t abandon the strategy entirely until you’ve given it a real chance.
The Bottom Line
None of these mistakes are complicated to fix. The problem is that most brands either don’t realize they’re making them or assume their industry is somehow different. It’s not. The algorithms don’t care what you sell – they care about engagement signals, consistency, and relevance.
Start by picking the 2-3 mistakes from this list that hit closest to home. Fix those first. Then work through the rest over the next month. Small, consistent improvements beat dramatic overhauls every time.
Your audience is out there. You just have to stop getting in your own way.
Ready to grow your business on social media?
Let’s build a strategy that turns followers into customers. Results that speak for themselves.
Need help building a social media strategy that actually drives results? Aslan Agency works with businesses and individuals ready to take their social presence seriously.